Merge pull request #3 from permissionlesstech/concurrent-relay-discovery

feat: concurrent relay discovery

.github/workflows/update-relay-data.yml

@@ -46,7 +46,7 @@ jobs:
     
     - name: Update relay discovery results
       run: |
-        python3 nostr_relay_discovery.py wss://relay.damus.io --output relay_discovery_results.json
+        python3 nostr_relay_discovery.py wss://relay.damus.io --output relay_discovery_results.json --batch-size 20
     
     - name: Update relay geolocation data
       run: |

nostr_relay_discovery.py

@@ -60,12 +60,13 @@ class RelayDiscoveryStats:
 class NostrRelayDiscovery:
     """Nostr relay discovery tool using breadth-first search through follow lists"""
     
-    def __init__(self, initial_relay: str, max_depth: int = 3, connection_timeout: int = 5, output_file: str = "relay_discovery_results.json", save_point: int = SAVE_POINT):
+    def __init__(self, initial_relay: str, max_depth: int = 3, connection_timeout: int = 5, output_file: str = "relay_discovery_results.json", save_point: int = SAVE_POINT, batch_size: int = 10):
         self.initial_relay = initial_relay
         self.max_depth = max_depth
         self.connection_timeout = connection_timeout
         self.output_file = output_file
         self.save_point = save_point
+        self.batch_size = batch_size
         
         # Discovery state
         self.to_visit: deque = deque()  # (relay_url, depth) - will be populated by load_existing_results
@@ -197,6 +198,38 @@ class NostrRelayDiscovery:
             logger.debug(f"Failed to connect to {relay_url}: {e}")
             return False
     
+    async def test_relays_connections(self, relay_urls: List[str]) -> Dict[str, bool]:
+        """Test multiple relays concurrently and return a dict of relay_url -> functioning status"""
+        if not relay_urls:
+            return {}
+        
+        logger.info(f"Testing {len(relay_urls)} relays concurrently")
+        
+        # Create tasks for concurrent testing
+        tasks = []
+        for relay_url in relay_urls:
+            task = asyncio.create_task(self.test_relay_connection(relay_url))
+            tasks.append((relay_url, task))
+        
+        # Wait for all tasks to complete
+        results = {}
+        for relay_url, task in tasks:
+            try:
+                is_functioning = await task
+                results[relay_url] = is_functioning
+                if is_functioning:
+                    logger.info(f"✓ Relay {relay_url} is functioning")
+                else:
+                    logger.warning(f"✗ Relay {relay_url} is not functioning")
+            except Exception as e:
+                logger.error(f"Error testing relay {relay_url}: {e}")
+                results[relay_url] = False
+        
+        functioning_count = sum(1 for status in results.values() if status)
+        logger.info(f"Batch test completed: {functioning_count}/{len(relay_urls)} relays functioning")
+        
+        return results
+    
     async def fetch_events(self, relay_url: str) -> List[Dict]:
         """Fetch kind 3 events (follow lists) or kind 10002 (NIP-66) from a relay"""
         follow_events = []
@@ -257,6 +290,35 @@ class NostrRelayDiscovery:
         logger.info(f"Collected {len(follow_events)} follow events from {relay_url}")
         return follow_events
 
+    async def fetch_events_from_relays(self, relay_urls: List[str]) -> Dict[str, List[Dict]]:
+        """Fetch events from multiple relays concurrently and return a dict of relay_url -> events"""
+        if not relay_urls:
+            return {}
+        
+        logger.info(f"Fetching events from {len(relay_urls)} relays concurrently")
+        
+        # Create tasks for concurrent event fetching
+        tasks = []
+        for relay_url in relay_urls:
+            task = asyncio.create_task(self.fetch_events(relay_url))
+            tasks.append((relay_url, task))
+        
+        # Wait for all tasks to complete
+        results = {}
+        for relay_url, task in tasks:
+            try:
+                events = await task
+                results[relay_url] = events
+                logger.info(f"✓ Fetched {len(events)} events from {relay_url}")
+            except Exception as e:
+                logger.error(f"Error fetching events from relay {relay_url}: {e}")
+                results[relay_url] = []
+        
+        total_events = sum(len(events) for events in results.values())
+        logger.info(f"Batch fetch completed: {total_events} total events from {len(relay_urls)} relays")
+        
+        return results
+
     
     def extract_relays_from_events(self, events: List[Dict]) -> Set[str]:
         """Extract relay URLs from follow list events"""
@@ -325,60 +387,79 @@ class NostrRelayDiscovery:
             return False
     
     async def discover_relays(self) -> Set[str]:
-        """Main discovery method using breadth-first search"""
+        """Main discovery method using breadth-first search with concurrent processing"""
         # First, try to load existing results and verify them
         logger.info("Checking for existing results to build upon...")
         await self.load_existing_results()
         
-        logger.info(f"Starting relay discovery from existing verified relays or {self.initial_relay}")
+        logger.info(f"Starting relay discovery with batch size {self.batch_size}")
         logger.info(f"Maximum depth: {self.max_depth}")
         
         while self.to_visit:
-            current_relay, depth = self.to_visit.popleft()
+            # Collect a batch of relays to process
-            self.to_visit_set.remove(current_relay)
+            current_batch = []
+            batch_depth_map = {}
             
-            # Skip if already visited
+            # Get up to batch_size relays from the queue
-            if current_relay in self.visited_relays:
+            for _ in range(min(self.batch_size, len(self.to_visit))):
-                continue
+                if not self.to_visit:
-            
+                    break
-            # Skip if depth exceeds maximum
+                    
-            if depth > self.max_depth:
+                current_relay, depth = self.to_visit.popleft()
-                logger.info(f"Reached maximum depth {self.max_depth}, stopping exploration")
+                self.to_visit_set.remove(current_relay)
-                continue
-            
-            logger.info(f"Processing relay {current_relay} at depth {depth}")
-            self.visited_relays.add(current_relay)
-            
-            if await self.test_relay_connection(current_relay):
-                logger.info(f"✓ Relay {current_relay} is functioning")
-                self.functioning_relays.add(current_relay)
-                self.stats.functioning_relays += 1
                 
-                # Only fetch follow lists if we haven't reached max depth
+                # Skip if already visited
-                if depth < self.max_depth:
+                if current_relay in self.visited_relays:
-                    try:
+                    continue
-                        # Fetch follow lists from this relay
+                    
-                        events = await self.fetch_events(current_relay)
+                # Skip if depth exceeds maximum
-                        
+                if depth > self.max_depth:
-                        if events:
+                    logger.info(f"Reached maximum depth {self.max_depth}, stopping exploration")
-                            # Extract new relays from follow lists
+                    continue
-                            new_relays = self.extract_relays_from_events(events)
-                            
-                            # Add new relays to visit queue for next depth level
-                            for relay_url in new_relays:
-                                if relay_url not in self.visited_relays and relay_url not in self.to_visit_set:
-                                    self.to_visit.append((relay_url, depth + 1))
-                                    self.to_visit_set.add(relay_url)
-                                    self.stats.total_relays_found += 1
-                                    logger.debug(f"Added {relay_url} to visit queue at depth {depth + 1}")
-                        
-                    except Exception as e:
-                        logger.error(f"Error processing relay {current_relay}: {e}")
                 
-            else:
+                current_batch.append(current_relay)
-                logger.warning(f"✗ Relay {current_relay} is not functioning")
+                batch_depth_map[current_relay] = depth
+                self.visited_relays.add(current_relay)
             
-            # Save progress periodically every save_point relays processed
+            if not current_batch:
+                break
+            
+            logger.info(f"Processing batch of {len(current_batch)} relays")
+            
+            # Test all relays in the batch concurrently
+            test_results = await self.test_relays_connections(current_batch)
+            
+            # Collect functioning relays for event fetching
+            functioning_relays_batch = []
+            for relay_url, is_functioning in test_results.items():
+                if is_functioning:
+                    self.functioning_relays.add(relay_url)
+                    self.stats.functioning_relays += 1
+                    
+                    # Only add to event fetching if we haven't reached max depth
+                    depth = batch_depth_map[relay_url]
+                    if depth < self.max_depth:
+                        functioning_relays_batch.append(relay_url)
+            
+            # Fetch events from all functioning relays concurrently
+            if functioning_relays_batch:
+                events_results = await self.fetch_events_from_relays(functioning_relays_batch)
+                
+                # Process events and extract new relays
+                for relay_url, events in events_results.items():
+                    if events:
+                        depth = batch_depth_map[relay_url]
+                        new_relays = self.extract_relays_from_events(events)
+                        
+                        # Add new relays to visit queue for next depth level
+                        for new_relay_url in new_relays:
+                            if new_relay_url not in self.visited_relays and new_relay_url not in self.to_visit_set:
+                                self.to_visit.append((new_relay_url, depth + 1))
+                                self.to_visit_set.add(new_relay_url)
+                                self.stats.total_relays_found += 1
+                                logger.debug(f"Added {new_relay_url} to visit queue at depth {depth + 1}")
+            
+            # Save progress periodically
             if len(self.visited_relays) % self.save_point == 0:
                 logger.info(f"Progress checkpoint: Saving results after processing {len(self.visited_relays)} relays")
                 self.save_results()
@@ -400,7 +481,8 @@ class NostrRelayDiscovery:
                 "initial_relay": self.initial_relay,
                 "max_depth": self.max_depth,
                 "connection_timeout": self.connection_timeout,
-                "save_point": self.save_point
+                "save_point": self.save_point,
+                "batch_size": self.batch_size
             },
             "progress_info": {
                 "relays_processed": len(self.visited_relays),
@@ -442,7 +524,7 @@ async def main():
         "--timeout",
         type=int,
         default=5,
-        help="Connection timeout in seconds (default: 10)"
+        help="Connection timeout in seconds (default: 5)"
     )
     parser.add_argument(
         "--output",
@@ -455,6 +537,12 @@ async def main():
         default=SAVE_POINT,
         help=f"Save progress every N relays processed (default: {SAVE_POINT})"
     )
+    parser.add_argument(
+        "--batch-size",
+        type=int,
+        default=10,
+        help="Number of relays to process concurrently (default: 10)"
+    )
     parser.add_argument(
         "--verbose",
         action="store_true",
@@ -467,7 +555,14 @@ async def main():
         logging.getLogger().setLevel(logging.DEBUG)
     
     # Validate initial relay URL
-    discovery = NostrRelayDiscovery(args.initial_relay, args.max_depth, args.timeout, args.output, args.save_point)
+    discovery = NostrRelayDiscovery(
+        args.initial_relay, 
+        args.max_depth, 
+        args.timeout, 
+        args.output, 
+        args.save_point,
+        args.batch_size
+    )
     if not discovery.is_valid_relay_url(args.initial_relay):
         print(f"Error: Invalid relay URL: {args.initial_relay}")
         print("Relay URL should start with ws:// or wss://")

nostr_relays.csv

@@ -1,265 +1,265 @@
 Relay URL,Latitude,Longitude
-nostr.red5d.dev,37.7621,-122.3971
-wot.soundhsa.com,39.0997,-94.5786
-relay.utxo.farm,34.7331,135.8183
-nostr.satstralia.com,64.1355,-21.8954
-relay.satlantis.io,32.8546,-79.9748
-relay.bullishbounty.com,37.7621,-122.3971
-relay.hook.cafe,37.7621,-122.3971
-wot.sebastix.social,51.3700,6.1681
-khatru.nostrver.se,51.3700,6.1681
-wheat.happytavern.co,37.7621,-122.3971
-nostrue.com,40.8043,-74.0121
-relay.javi.space,43.4628,11.8807
-nostr.pleb.one,38.6273,-90.1979
-relay.snort.social,53.3331,-6.2489
-relay.letsfo.com,52.2298,21.0118
-n.ok0.org,-36.8485,174.7635
-relay.nostromo.social,49.4542,11.0775
-nostr.zenon.network,40.7143,-74.0060
-relay02.lnfi.network,39.0997,-94.5786
-relay.agorist.space,52.3740,4.8897
-nostr.carroarmato0.be,50.8517,3.6089
-nostr-02.czas.top,51.2217,6.7762
-relay.moinsen.com,50.4779,12.3713
-nostr.thaliyal.com,40.8220,-74.4488
-nostream.breadslice.com,37.7621,-122.3971
-cyberspace.nostr1.com,40.7143,-74.0060
-relay5.bitransfer.org,37.7621,-122.3971
-relay.artiostr.ch,37.7621,-122.3971
-nostr.data.haus,50.4779,12.3713
-relay.jeffg.fyi,43.7064,-79.3986
-nostrelites.org,41.8500,-87.6500
-wot.dtonon.com,37.7621,-122.3971
-relay.exit.pub,50.4779,12.3713
-nostr.spicyz.io,37.7621,-122.3971
-black.nostrcity.club,41.8119,-87.6873
-nostr.jfischer.org,49.4453,11.0222
-relay04.lnfi.network,39.0997,-94.5786
-solo.itsalldance.space,32.7244,-96.6755
-relay.2nix.de,60.1695,24.9354
-relay.fountain.fm,39.0997,-94.5786
-relay.chakany.systems,37.7621,-122.3971
-nostr.mom,50.4779,12.3713
-relay.mess.ch,47.1345,9.0964
-inbox.azzamo.net,52.2284,21.0522
-relay.siamdev.cc,13.9178,100.4240
-nostr.openhoofd.nl,51.5717,3.7042
-relay.cypherflow.ai,48.8534,2.3488
-nos.lol,50.4779,12.3713
-relay.tagayasu.xyz,45.4112,-75.6981
-relay.puresignal.news,37.7621,-122.3971
-nos.xmark.cc,51.0344,2.3768
-relay.bitcoinartclock.com,50.4779,12.3713
-nostr.tadryanom.me,37.7621,-122.3971
-relay.nostx.io,37.7621,-122.3971
-nostr.einundzwanzig.space,50.1155,8.6842
-nostr-relay.online,37.7621,-122.3971
-relay.arx-ccn.com,50.4779,12.3713
-no.str.cr,9.9339,-84.0849
-relay.g1sms.fr,43.9298,2.1480
-r.bitcoinhold.net,37.7621,-122.3971
-relay.nostr.net,50.4779,12.3713
-nostr.makibisskey.work,37.7621,-122.3971
-relay.endfiat.money,37.7621,-122.3971
-strfry.bonsai.com,37.8716,-122.2728
-relay.nostrhub.fr,50.1155,8.6842
-srtrelay.c-stellar.net,37.7621,-122.3971
-prl.plus,55.7522,37.6156
-vitor.nostr1.com,40.7143,-74.0060
-librerelay.aaroniumii.com,37.7621,-122.3971
-relay.coinos.io,37.7621,-122.3971
-nostr-relay.psfoundation.info,39.0437,-77.4875
-ithurtswhenip.ee,50.7990,-1.0913
-nostr.myshosholoza.co.za,52.3710,4.9042
-nostr.lojong.info,37.7621,-122.3971
-relay.mattybs.lol,37.7621,-122.3971
-relay.olas.app,50.4779,12.3713
-nostr.azzamo.net,52.2284,21.0522
-relay.goodmorningbitcoin.com,37.7621,-122.3971
-relay.bitcoinveneto.org,64.1355,-21.8954
-relay.fr13nd5.com,50.1155,8.6842
-nostr-relay-1.trustlessenterprise.com,37.7621,-122.3971
-relay.cosmicbolt.net,37.3924,-121.9623
-purpura.cloud,37.7621,-122.3971
-nostr-rs-relay.dev.fedibtc.com,39.0437,-77.4875
-nostr.massmux.com,50.1155,8.6842
-nostr.21crypto.ch,46.5160,6.6328
-slick.mjex.me,39.0437,-77.4875
-nostr-03.dorafactory.org,1.2897,103.8501
-relayone.geektank.ai,17.1210,-61.8433
-relay.barine.co,37.7621,-122.3971
-nostr.2b9t.xyz,34.0522,-118.2437
-relay.nostr.vet,52.5273,5.7228
-relay.holzeis.me,37.7621,-122.3971
-nostr.sagaciousd.com,49.2497,-123.1193
-fanfares.nostr1.com,40.7143,-74.0060
-pyramid.fiatjaf.com,50.1155,8.6842
-santo.iguanatech.net,40.8344,-74.1377
-dev-relay.lnfi.network,39.0997,-94.5786
-strfry.shock.network,41.8847,-88.2040
-nostr.liberty.fans,38.8003,-90.6265
-wot.geektank.ai,17.1210,-61.8433
-relay.mostro.network,40.8344,-74.1377
-relay.toastr.net,40.8043,-74.0121
-nostr.camalolo.com,24.1469,120.6839
-relay.illuminodes.com,47.6062,-122.3321
-relay03.lnfi.network,39.0997,-94.5786
-relayone.soundhsa.com,39.0997,-94.5786
-nostr.jerrynya.fun,31.2222,121.4581
-nostr-02.yakihonne.com,1.3215,103.6957
-nostr.blankfors.se,60.1695,24.9354
-a.nos.lol,50.4779,12.3713
-relay.nostrhub.tech,49.4453,11.0222
-wot.nostr.net,37.7621,-122.3971
-relayrs.notoshi.win,37.7621,-122.3971
-fenrir-s.notoshi.win,37.7621,-122.3971
-relay.nostrdice.com,-33.8678,151.2073
-nostr.hekster.org,37.3924,-121.9623
-nostr.mikoshi.de,51.2217,6.7762
-theoutpost.life,64.1355,-21.8954
-nostr.overmind.lol,37.7621,-122.3971
-relay.nostar.org,37.7621,-122.3971
-satsage.xyz,37.3924,-121.9623
-nostr-relay.shirogaku.xyz,37.7621,-122.3971
-nostr-rs-relay-ishosta.phamthanh.me,37.7621,-122.3971
-nostr-relay.cbrx.io,37.7621,-122.3971
-relay.wavlake.com,41.2619,-95.8608
-nostr.l484.com,30.2960,-97.6396
-wot.codingarena.top,50.4779,12.3713
-wot.nostr.party,36.1659,-86.7844
-relay.21e6.cz,50.0880,14.4208
-dev-nostr.bityacht.io,25.0531,121.5264
-nostr.vulpem.com,49.4542,11.0775
-soloco.nl,37.7621,-122.3971
-relay.copylaradio.com,50.7990,-1.0913
-nostr.notribe.net,40.8344,-74.1377
-inbox.mycelium.social,38.6273,-90.1979
-relay2.angor.io,50.1155,8.6842
-relay.nostraddress.com,37.7621,-122.3971
-temp.iris.to,37.7621,-122.3971
-nostr.thebiglake.org,32.7244,-96.6755
-relay.dwadziesciajeden.pl,52.2298,21.0118
-nostr.roundrockbitcoiners.com,40.8043,-74.0121
-inbox.relays.land,50.1155,8.6842
-premium.primal.net,37.7621,-122.3971
-relay.lumina.rocks,49.4453,11.0222
-adre.su,59.9386,30.3141
-social.proxymana.net,60.1695,24.9354
-nostrelay.circum.space,51.4566,7.0123
-zap.watch,45.5088,-73.5878
 relay.nostriot.com,43.7064,-79.3986
-schnorr.me,37.7621,-122.3971
+relay.satlantis.io,32.8546,-79.9748
-relay.credenso.cafe,43.4254,-80.5112
-nostr-2.21crypto.ch,46.5160,6.6328
-nproxy.kristapsk.lv,60.1695,24.9354
-purplerelay.com,50.1155,8.6842
-nostr.smut.cloud,37.7621,-122.3971
-nostr.coincards.com,43.7064,-79.3986
-nostr-relay.amethyst.name,35.7721,-78.6386
-kitchen.zap.cooking,37.7621,-122.3971
-nostr.huszonegy.world,47.4984,19.0404
-nostr.rblb.it,37.7621,-122.3971
-nostr.rikmeijer.nl,50.4779,12.3713
-nostr.yael.at,52.3740,4.8897
-nostr.rtvslawenia.com,49.4542,11.0775
-noxir.kpherox.dev,34.8436,135.5084
-nostr.4rs.nl,49.4453,11.0222
-shu02.shugur.net,21.4901,39.1862
-relay.freeplace.nl,52.3740,4.8897
-relay.evanverma.com,40.8344,-74.1377
-nostr.community.ath.cx,45.5088,-73.5878
-nostr.n7ekb.net,47.5707,-122.2221
-relay.mwaters.net,50.9519,1.8563
-freelay.sovbit.host,64.1355,-21.8954
-relay.electriclifestyle.com,26.1223,-80.1434
-relay.nostr.band,60.1695,24.9354
-relay.notoshi.win,13.3622,100.9835
-relay.0xchat.com,1.2897,103.8501
-relay.chorus.community,50.1155,8.6842
-relay.nostr.wirednet.jp,35.9356,139.3044
-relay.magiccity.live,25.8130,-80.2320
-shu04.shugur.net,25.0772,55.3093
-relay.stream.labs.h3.se,59.3294,18.0687
-nostr-01.yakihonne.com,1.3215,103.6957
-relay.hasenpfeffr.com,39.0437,-77.4875
-relay.artx.market,43.7064,-79.3986
-relay.satsdays.com,1.2897,103.8501
-portal-relay.pareto.space,49.4453,11.0222
-vidono.apps.slidestr.net,48.8534,2.3488
-nostr.kungfu-g.rip,33.7865,-84.4454
-nostr.plantroon.com,50.1025,8.6299
-relay.lifpay.me,1.2897,103.8501
-relay-rpi.edufeed.org,49.4453,11.0222
-nostr.stakey.net,52.5250,5.7181
-wot.sudocarlos.com,43.7064,-79.3986
-relay.orangepill.ovh,49.0127,1.9694
-relay.digitalezukunft.cyou,45.5088,-73.5878
-nostr.chaima.info,50.1155,8.6842
-relay.degmods.com,50.4779,12.3713
-relay.varke.eu,52.6958,6.1944
-relay-testnet.k8s.layer3.news,37.3394,-121.8950
-strfry.felixzieger.de,50.1025,8.6299
-relay.lnfi.network,38.9209,-77.5039
-x.kojira.io,37.7621,-122.3971
-nostr.sathoarder.com,48.5839,7.7455
-relay-dev.satlantis.io,40.8344,-74.1377
-relay.getsafebox.app,43.7064,-79.3986
-gnostr.com,42.6975,23.3241
-wot.brightbolt.net,47.6928,-116.7850
-shu05.shugur.net,48.8534,2.3488
-relay.nsnip.io,60.1695,24.9354
-nostr.bilthon.dev,25.8130,-80.2320
-relay.sincensura.org,37.7621,-122.3971
-nostr.tac.lol,47.4740,-122.2610
-yabu.me,35.6090,139.7302
-travis-shears-nostr-relay-v2.fly.dev,41.8119,-87.6873
-nostrja-kari.heguro.com,37.7621,-122.3971
-orangesync.tech,50.9333,6.9500
-nostr.agentcampfire.com,52.3740,4.8897
-relay.angor.io,50.1155,8.6842
-nostr.middling.mydns.jp,35.8089,140.1185
-nostr.spaceshell.xyz,37.7621,-122.3971
-relay.13room.space,37.7621,-122.3971
-nostr.snowbla.de,60.1695,24.9354
 relay.laantungir.net,45.5088,-73.5878
-nostr.rohoss.com,48.1374,11.5755
+relay.2nix.de,60.1695,24.9354
-nostr.diakod.com,37.7621,-122.3971
+relay.artx.market,43.7064,-79.3986
-nostr.hifish.org,47.3667,8.5500
-nostr.0x7e.xyz,47.5056,8.7241
-relay.wolfcoil.com,35.6090,139.7302
-relay.davidebtc.me,50.1155,8.6842
 relay.hodl.ar,-32.9468,-60.6393
-relay.etch.social,41.2619,-95.8608
+relay.0xchat.com,1.2897,103.8501
-strfry.openhoofd.nl,51.5717,3.7042
+relay.nostar.org,37.7621,-122.3971
-relay.ru.ac.th,13.7540,100.5014
+wot.dtonon.com,37.7621,-122.3971
-relay.ngengine.org,53.3331,-6.2489
+relayone.soundhsa.com,39.0997,-94.5786
-nostr.kalf.org,52.3740,4.8897
-relay.nosto.re,51.3700,6.1681
-nostr.now,35.6090,139.7302
-wot.nostr.place,30.2672,-97.7431
-relay.damus.io,37.7621,-122.3971
 relay.primal.net,37.7621,-122.3971
-relay.zone667.com,60.1695,24.9354
+relay.holzeis.me,37.7621,-122.3971
-relay.usefusion.ai,38.7135,-78.1594
+nostr.overmind.lol,37.7621,-122.3971
-relay.mccormick.cx,52.3740,4.8897
+relay.chakany.systems,37.7621,-122.3971
-alien.macneilmediagroup.com,37.7621,-122.3971
+x.kojira.io,37.7621,-122.3971
-orangepiller.org,60.1695,24.9354
+relay.mostro.network,40.8344,-74.1377
-offchain.pub,34.0522,-118.2437
-nostr-relay.zimage.com,34.0522,-118.2437
-tollbooth.stens.dev,51.4566,7.0123
-relay.vrtmrz.net,37.7621,-122.3971
-nostrelay.memory-art.xyz,37.7621,-122.3971
-relay-admin.thaliyal.com,40.8220,-74.4488
 relay.tapestry.ninja,40.8043,-74.0121
-nostr.oxtr.dev,50.4779,12.3713
+relay.satsdays.com,1.2897,103.8501
-articles.layer3.news,37.3394,-121.8950
-relay.conduit.market,37.7621,-122.3971
-internationalright-wing.org,-22.5986,-48.8003
-relay01.lnfi.network,39.0997,-94.5786
-nostr-02.dorafactory.org,1.2897,103.8501
-nostr.coincrowd.fund,39.0437,-77.4875
-ribo.eu.nostria.app,52.3740,4.8897
-nostr.night7.space,50.4779,12.3713
-relay.bitcoindistrict.org,37.7621,-122.3971
 relay.sigit.io,50.4779,12.3713
+nostr-02.yakihonne.com,1.3215,103.6957
+inbox.azzamo.net,52.2284,21.0522
+ribo.eu.nostria.app,52.3740,4.8897
+nostr.coincrowd.fund,39.0437,-77.4875
+relay.snort.social,53.3331,-6.2489
+wheat.happytavern.co,37.7621,-122.3971
+relay.mess.ch,47.1345,9.0964
+zap.watch,45.5088,-73.5878
+relay.exit.pub,50.4779,12.3713
+nostr-relay.zimage.com,34.0522,-118.2437
+relay.illuminodes.com,47.6062,-122.3321
+nostr.massmux.com,50.1155,8.6842
+nostr.zenon.network,40.7143,-74.0060
+strfry.openhoofd.nl,51.5717,3.7042
+nostr-rs-relay.dev.fedibtc.com,39.0437,-77.4875
+vidono.apps.slidestr.net,48.8534,2.3488
+r.bitcoinhold.net,37.7621,-122.3971
+nostr-relay.cbrx.io,37.7621,-122.3971
+relay.chorus.community,50.1155,8.6842
+relay.tagayasu.xyz,45.4112,-75.6981
+wot.downisontheup.ca,47.6062,-122.3321
+nostr.snowbla.de,60.1695,24.9354
+relay.lnfi.network,37.3394,-121.8950
+satsage.xyz,37.3924,-121.9623
+relay.usefusion.ai,38.7135,-78.1594
+nostr.red5d.dev,37.7621,-122.3971
+nostr-relay.shirogaku.xyz,37.7621,-122.3971
+social.proxymana.net,60.1695,24.9354
+cyberspace.nostr1.com,40.7143,-74.0060
+relay.g1sms.fr,43.9298,2.1480
+prl.plus,55.7522,37.6156
+nos.lol,50.4779,12.3713
+wot.nostr.place,30.2672,-97.7431
+nostrelay.circum.space,51.4566,7.0123
+strfry.felixzieger.de,50.1025,8.6299
+relay.nosto.re,51.3700,6.1681
+relay01.lnfi.network,39.0997,-94.5786
+relay.ngengine.org,53.3331,-6.2489
+relay.bullishbounty.com,37.7621,-122.3971
+nostr.openhoofd.nl,51.5717,3.7042
+nostr.0x7e.xyz,47.5056,8.7241
+relay-rpi.edufeed.org,49.4453,11.0222
+relayrs.notoshi.win,37.7621,-122.3971
+temp.iris.to,37.7621,-122.3971
+nostr.spaceshell.xyz,37.7621,-122.3971
+relay.jeffg.fyi,43.7064,-79.3986
+nostr.rohoss.com,48.1374,11.5755
+nostr.vulpem.com,49.4542,11.0775
+nostr-02.czas.top,51.2217,6.7762
+a.nos.lol,50.4779,12.3713
+nostr.pleb.one,38.6273,-90.1979
+relay.nostrdice.com,-33.8678,151.2073
+relay.credenso.cafe,43.4254,-80.5112
+relay.wolfcoil.com,35.6090,139.7302
+no.str.cr,9.9339,-84.0849
+relay-dev.satlantis.io,40.8344,-74.1377
+nostr.liberty.fans,38.8003,-90.6265
+relay.bitcoindistrict.org,37.7621,-122.3971
+relay.arx-ccn.com,50.4779,12.3713
+relay.conduit.market,37.7621,-122.3971
+nostr.rikmeijer.nl,50.4779,12.3713
+nostr.sathoarder.com,48.5839,7.7455
+nostrelites.org,41.8500,-87.6500
+relay.mattybs.lol,37.7621,-122.3971
+nostr.spicyz.io,37.7621,-122.3971
+fanfares.nostr1.com,40.7143,-74.0060
+nostr.coincards.com,43.7064,-79.3986
+nostr.tac.lol,47.4740,-122.2610
+relay.copylaradio.com,50.7990,-1.0913
+dev-nostr.bityacht.io,25.0531,121.5264
+relay.olas.app,50.4779,12.3713
+articles.layer3.news,37.3394,-121.8950
+nostr.diakod.com,37.7621,-122.3971
+relay.nostraddress.com,37.7621,-122.3971
+relay.sincensura.org,37.7621,-122.3971
+relay.vrtmrz.net,37.7621,-122.3971
+nostr.mikoshi.de,51.2217,6.7762
+nostr.thaliyal.com,40.8220,-74.4488
+shu05.shugur.net,48.8534,2.3488
+orangepiller.org,60.1695,24.9354
+relay.mockingyou.com,37.5483,-121.9886
+nostr.primz.org,37.7621,-122.3971
+nostr-relay.amethyst.name,35.7721,-78.6386
+relay.lifpay.me,1.2897,103.8501
+nproxy.kristapsk.lv,60.1695,24.9354
+relay.etch.social,41.2619,-95.8608
+relay.siamdev.cc,13.9178,100.4240
+relay.goodmorningbitcoin.com,37.7621,-122.3971
+nostr.rblb.it,37.7621,-122.3971
+relay.nsnip.io,60.1695,24.9354
+nostr.myshosholoza.co.za,52.3710,4.9042
+relay.varke.eu,52.6958,6.1944
+nostr.agentcampfire.com,52.3740,4.8897
+relay.barine.co,37.7621,-122.3971
+gnostr.com,42.6975,23.3241
+offchain.pub,34.0522,-118.2437
+strfry.shock.network,41.8847,-88.2040
+relay03.lnfi.network,39.0997,-94.5786
+nostr.tadryanom.me,37.7621,-122.3971
+relay.zone667.com,60.1695,24.9354
+relay.21e6.cz,50.0880,14.4208
+nostrue.com,40.8043,-74.0121
+nostr.kalf.org,52.3740,4.8897
+relay.cosmicbolt.net,37.3924,-121.9623
+relay04.lnfi.network,39.0997,-94.5786
+relay.freeplace.nl,52.3740,4.8897
+relay02.lnfi.network,39.0997,-94.5786
+relay2.angor.io,50.1155,8.6842
+relay.mccormick.cx,52.3740,4.8897
+nostr.kungfu-g.rip,33.7865,-84.4454
+nostr.n7ekb.net,47.5707,-122.2221
+nostr.jerrynya.fun,31.2222,121.4581
+travis-shears-nostr-relay-v2.fly.dev,41.8119,-87.6873
+nostr.l484.com,30.2960,-97.6396
+purplerelay.com,50.1155,8.6842
+soloco.nl,37.7621,-122.3971
+nostr.oxtr.dev,50.4779,12.3713
+nostr-relay.online,37.7621,-122.3971
+relay.nostr.wirednet.jp,35.9356,139.3044
+nostr-rs-relay-ishosta.phamthanh.me,37.7621,-122.3971
+wot.sudocarlos.com,43.7064,-79.3986
+relay.lumina.rocks,49.4453,11.0222
+relay.cypherflow.ai,48.8534,2.3488
+relay.fr13nd5.com,50.1155,8.6842
+nostr.einundzwanzig.space,50.1155,8.6842
+nostr.roundrockbitcoiners.com,40.8043,-74.0121
+adre.su,59.9386,30.3141
+relay.digitalezukunft.cyou,45.5088,-73.5878
+kitchen.zap.cooking,37.7621,-122.3971
+nostr.thebiglake.org,32.7244,-96.6755
+wot.nostr.party,36.1659,-86.7844
+relay-testnet.k8s.layer3.news,37.3394,-121.8950
+nostr-relay-1.trustlessenterprise.com,37.7621,-122.3971
+schnorr.me,37.7621,-122.3971
+nostr.bilthon.dev,25.8130,-80.2320
+relay.ru.ac.th,13.7540,100.5014
+nostr.sagaciousd.com,49.2497,-123.1193
+inbox.relays.land,50.1155,8.6842
+nostr.jfischer.org,49.4453,11.0222
+nostr.stakey.net,52.5250,5.7181
+nostrja-kari.heguro.com,37.7621,-122.3971
+fenrir-s.notoshi.win,37.7621,-122.3971
+relay.dwadziesciajeden.pl,52.2298,21.0118
+nostr-02.dorafactory.org,1.2897,103.8501
+nostr.now,35.6090,139.7302
+nostream.breadslice.com,37.7621,-122.3971
+shu02.shugur.net,21.4901,39.1862
+librerelay.aaroniumii.com,37.7621,-122.3971
+nostr.middling.mydns.jp,35.8089,140.1185
+relay.nostrcheck.me,37.7621,-122.3971
+relay.getsafebox.app,43.7064,-79.3986
+shu04.shugur.net,25.0772,55.3093
+alien.macneilmediagroup.com,37.7621,-122.3971
+nostr.community.ath.cx,45.5088,-73.5878
+relay.nostrhub.fr,50.1155,8.6842
+relay.moinsen.com,50.4779,12.3713
+relay.nostr.net,50.4779,12.3713
+noxir.kpherox.dev,34.8436,135.5084
+relay.damus.io,37.7621,-122.3971
+relay.bitcoinveneto.org,64.1355,-21.8954
+nostr.hifish.org,47.3667,8.5500
+nostr.yael.at,52.3740,4.8897
+relay.nostr.band,60.1695,24.9354
+relay.utxo.farm,34.7331,135.8183
+relay.hook.cafe,37.7621,-122.3971
+nostr.camalolo.com,24.1469,120.6839
+premium.primal.net,37.7621,-122.3971
+dev-relay.lnfi.network,39.0997,-94.5786
+relay.evanverma.com,40.8344,-74.1377
+nostr.blankfors.se,60.1695,24.9354
+relay.bitcoinartclock.com,50.4779,12.3713
+black.nostrcity.club,41.8119,-87.6873
+relay.nostx.io,37.7621,-122.3971
+nostr.huszonegy.world,47.4984,19.0404
+nostr.carroarmato0.be,50.8517,3.6089
+nostr.21crypto.ch,46.5160,6.6328
+relay-admin.thaliyal.com,40.8220,-74.4488
+nos.xmark.cc,51.0344,2.3768
+khatru.nostrver.se,51.3700,6.1681
+wot.codingarena.top,50.4779,12.3713
+internationalright-wing.org,-22.5986,-48.8003
+relay.stream.labs.h3.se,59.3294,18.0687
+nostr-2.21crypto.ch,46.5160,6.6328
+relay.puresignal.news,37.7621,-122.3971
+solo.itsalldance.space,32.7244,-96.6755
+slick.mjex.me,39.0437,-77.4875
+pyramid.fiatjaf.com,50.1155,8.6842
+portal-relay.pareto.space,49.4453,11.0222
+relay.hasenpfeffr.com,39.0437,-77.4875
+relay.degmods.com,50.4779,12.3713
+strfry.bonsai.com,37.8716,-122.2728
+relay.wavlake.com,41.2619,-95.8608
+orangesync.tech,50.9333,6.9500
+nostr.smut.cloud,37.7621,-122.3971
+inbox.mycelium.social,38.6273,-90.1979
+nostr.satstralia.com,64.1355,-21.8954
+nostr-relay.psfoundation.info,39.0437,-77.4875
+nostr.rtvslawenia.com,49.4542,11.0775
+nostr.lojong.info,37.7621,-122.3971
+nostr.plantroon.com,50.1025,8.6299
+relay.toastr.net,40.8043,-74.0121
+relay.nostrhub.tech,49.4453,11.0222
+relay.nostromo.social,49.4542,11.0775
+yabu.me,35.6090,139.7302
+n.ok0.org,-36.8485,174.7635
+wot.brightbolt.net,47.6928,-116.7850
+relay.javi.space,43.4628,11.8807
+vitor.nostr1.com,40.7143,-74.0060
+relay.notoshi.win,13.3622,100.9835
+relay.coinos.io,37.7621,-122.3971
+wot.nostr.net,37.7621,-122.3971
+nostr.night7.space,50.4779,12.3713
+nostr.azzamo.net,52.2284,21.0522
+nostrelay.memory-art.xyz,37.7621,-122.3971
+relay.13room.space,37.7621,-122.3971
+relay.agorist.space,52.3740,4.8897
+relay.artiostr.ch,37.7621,-122.3971
+relay.letsfo.com,52.2298,21.0118
+relay.mwaters.net,50.9519,1.8563
+nostr.makibisskey.work,37.7621,-122.3971
+theoutpost.life,64.1355,-21.8954
+nostr.mom,50.4779,12.3713
+santo.iguanatech.net,40.8344,-74.1377
+nostr-03.dorafactory.org,1.2897,103.8501
+nostr.data.haus,50.4779,12.3713
+nostr.2b9t.xyz,34.0522,-118.2437
+relay.endfiat.money,37.7621,-122.3971
+srtrelay.c-stellar.net,37.7621,-122.3971
+relay.electriclifestyle.com,26.1223,-80.1434
+nostr-01.yakihonne.com,1.3215,103.6957
+nostr.hekster.org,37.3924,-121.9623
+relay.magiccity.live,25.8130,-80.2320
+relay.orangepill.ovh,49.0127,1.9694
+relay5.bitransfer.org,37.7621,-122.3971
+nostr.4rs.nl,49.4453,11.0222
+tollbooth.stens.dev,51.4566,7.0123
+wot.soundhsa.com,39.0997,-94.5786
+relay.nostr.vet,52.5273,5.7228
+relay.davidebtc.me,50.1155,8.6842
+nostr.chaima.info,50.1155,8.6842
+wot.sebastix.social,51.3700,6.1681
+relay.angor.io,50.1155,8.6842
+nostr.notribe.net,40.8344,-74.1377
+purpura.cloud,37.7621,-122.3971
+wot.geektank.ai,17.1210,-61.8433