jackandClaude Opus 5 c9f2f418ca Fix two P1 flaws in the recognition tag design (Codex #1487) ...

Both findings are correct and both were real. This is the argument for
shipping code next to the prose: neither was obvious in the design text.

**Tags were symmetric, which leaked the social graph.** `HMAC(K_AB, epoch)`
produces the same 8 bytes for both parties, so an observer who saw one
value in two different announces would learn those two devices are mutual
favourites, and could link their two rotating IDs to each other — handing
over exactly the graph the design exists to hide, plus a cross-epoch
correlation handle. Tags are now directional: the MAC covers the ordered
sender and recipient static public keys, so A→B and B→A differ. Both
parties can still compute both directions because both hold both keys.

**Tags were replayable under any ID.** A tag depending only on
(pair, epoch) could be lifted from a recorded announce and replayed in a
fresh announce under an attacker-chosen ID; the recipient would match and
treat that ID as the favourite, and since epoch-1 is accepted it would
keep working into the next period. The MAC now covers the announced peer
ID, which reduces this to replaying the victim's own presence.

That residual is unfixable while announces are unsigned, so the spec now
states plainly that recognition is a hint only: presence may be populated,
but routing a DM or showing a verified badge must wait for a handshake
whose static key equals the favourite that produced the match. O4 is
rewritten around that, with the two alternatives named (per-epoch
ephemeral signing key, or a freshness nonce echoed by the recipient).

Tests: two regression cases named for the findings, plus a
wrong-direction-does-not-match case so the directional fix cannot silently
become cosmetic. The vector table now gives both directions, because their
difference is the security property — an implementation that produces one
value for both has reintroduced the flaw. Recomputed independently in
Python from the spec and matched byte for byte.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>

2026-07-26 20:49:10 +02:00

..

BitFoundationTests

Fix two P1 flaws in the recognition tag design (Codex #1487)

2026-07-26 20:49:10 +02:00